Not long ago, defined benefit (DB) pension schemes formed the backbone of retirement planning for millions of workers across the UK. These pensions promised a guaranteed income for life based on your salary and years of service – providing peace of mind that few options today can match.
But that level of assurance is now a rarity. Between 2012 and 2023, the percentage of schemes open to new members fell from 11% to just 4%, continuing the major shift away from DB pensions. So, what’s changed?
Increased longevity
People are living longer, and that’s a good thing – until you try to plan how long your pension needs to last. In a DB scheme, employers commit to paying you a set amount every year after you retire, often for decades. Higher life expectancies mean the sum of these payments is far larger than it once was.
It all means defined benefit pension schemes are more expensive to maintain. Organisations must either contribute larger amounts of money to schemes or face growing deficits, both of which are financially unsustainable over the long term.
Risk management
In DB schemes, the employer takes on nearly all the financial risk. If the fund underperforms or if inflation rises unexpectedly, it’s up to the company to fill the gap. This creates huge uncertainty, especially during times of market volatility.
Defined contribution (DC) schemes, now the standard, shift that risk to the employee. Although this might feel less secure, it gives employers greater control over their long-term financial planning. For many businesses, this change has simply been a matter of survival.
Cost pressures
Rising costs have squeezed both public and private employers. Companies need to stay competitive while managing increasingly tight budgets. Offering a DB pension may feel like a financial luxury they can’t afford.
For example, funding a DB pension might require an employer to contribute up to 30% of a worker’s salary each year, compared to much lower percentages for DC schemes. These cost differences have played a major role in phasing out DB pensions.
A changing system, not a failing one
Defined benefit pensions became difficult to sustain in a world where people live longer, markets shift quickly and businesses face rising costs. The industry has adapted mostly out of necessity, not preference.
While newer pension models place greater responsibility on your shoulders, they also offer more flexibility and portability, which may suit how you work and live today. Knowing how the system evolved can help you make informed choices about your retirement, even if the golden guarantees of the past are not on offer anymore.